Vermont's Health Bureaucracy - Is it for YOU?

Jennifer Stella's picture
Editors Note:

Read proposed revisions to Vermont’s Vaccination Regulations here. Changes are meant to reflect the Health Department's interpretation of Act 157.

There will be a PUBLIC HEARING at the Vermont Department of Health (108 Cherry Street, Burlington) on 10/19/2012 from 9:30-11:30. Please come!

Visit VaxChoiceVT on the web or on facebook.

Sun, 09/16/2012 - 10:38pm

In an unprecedented meeting with VaxChoiceVT coalition members, last week Tracy Dolan from the Vermont Department of Health acknowledged the Health Department’s awareness of our concerns regarding compelled speech on their self-proclaimed Religious and Philosophical Vaccine Exemption Form.

Dolan is the Deputy Commissioner of Health. A native of British Colombia and herself a mother of two, she indicated that proposed regulation changes – which propose strict enforcement through childcare and school administrators - have been reviewed and approved by the Department of Children and Families and the Department of Education.

The Vermont Department of Health is largely funded from outside of our state, and yet possesses extraordinary power.  Last year,  $23,793,896 flowed from Federal taxpayers to the CDC and back to Vermont. This represents approximately 80% of the Health Department’s total budget. The CDC comes under the umbrella of the Federal Department of Health and Human Services, headed by Kathleen Sebelius. Next year (2013), CDC wants $13 billion from Federal taxpayers.

The CDC is carrying out an aggressive campaign to limit the rights of US citizens in the name of public health, and the Vermont Department of Health, headed by Dr. Harry Chen, seems to be more than willing to implement. As Health Comssioner, Chen has been granted special power to decide what constitutes a health risk and to propose action that may very well include the loss of rights that many of us consider to be inalienable and basic human rights.

The Vermont Coalition for Vaccine Choice aims to preserve our right to take responsibility for our own health by calling for preservation of true informed consent and a Vermonters right to choose. An all-volunteer organization, this spring we managed to successfully advocate on behalf of over 1500 citizens who want the right to make their own health choices when it comes to medical decisions for our children.Unwitting supporters of the compulsory vaccination of schoolchildren fail to realize the freedoms they may soon give up for themselves, as the adult vaccine schedule rises to the top of the CDC (and therefore the Health Department's) agenda. 

UPDATE (9/17/2012):  The freedom to make important health choices must stay in the hands of the people of Vermont. And yet Vermont's Health Commissioner has already been granted inordinate power by the Vermont legislature. This is a problem that is beginning to spill out beyond the vaccine mandate policy he is pursuing. For example, VTDigger.org reported today on Chen's unilateral decision to blanket pesticide over Vermont:

"The legal basis for the state spraying pesticides over hundreds of private properties stems from DOH Commissioner Harry Chen’s determination that the recent episodes of EEE were a 'significant public health risk.'

Under title 18 of the Vermont statutes, 'Significant public health risk’ means a 'public health risk of such magnitude that the commissioner or a local health officer has reason to believe that it must be mitigated. The magnitude of the risk is a factor of the characteristics of the public health hazard and the degree and the circumstances of exposure to such public health hazard.'
 
According to Pat Parenteau, former commissioner of the Vermont Department of Environmental Conservation and law professor at Vermont Law School, that language gives the commissioner an extraordinary amount of power.
 
'That’s what I’d call unbridled discretion,' he said. 'That basically commits the decision to the discretion of the commissioner. There are no objective standards there at all.'
 
Parenteau said he doesn’t know of any firm legal grounds by which to challenge decisions made by the commissioner during such an event. The legislature made a rule, he said, that put an enormous amount of faith in the abilities of a health commissioner to make quick and crucial decisions during an emergency."
 
The question now is: can we recover this power to make health choices in line with our values? The answer may very well be an independent Vermont.